BAKFlip F1, known for its premium blend of aluminum panels with a fiberglass reinforced polymer top, offers exceptional durability and advanced weather resistance.
On the other hand, the Gator FX3, entirely crafted from fiberglass reinforced polymer, provides a lightweight yet sturdy solution for truck owners.
It excels in both resilience against external elements and ease of use, with a focus on both protection and accessibility.
Both covers look exactly the same but which one will suit you better? More information is on the way.
Bottom line:
BAKFlip F1 stands out with its sturdy build and impressive water resistance, though it’s pricier with a 5-year warranty. Gator FX3, on the other hand, is easier to handle due to its lighter panels, comes at almost the same with a 2-year warranty. However, its seals need adjustments and it has minor water resistance issues.
Table of Contents
Quick Highlights
Shared features
- Full bed access.
- Aluminum bottom layer.
- FRP top layer.
BAKFlip F1 excels in
- Water Resistance: It is highly resistant to water.
- Longer Warranty: It offers 5 year warranty.
- Build Quality: Sturdy and durable, can carry 400lbs on top of it.
But where BAKFlip F1 lacks? Click the highlighted text to review this cover.
Gator FX3 takes lead in
- Easy Installation: One-person job, around an hour, no extra tools needed.
- Accessibility: Light weight panels are easy to use.
- Affordable: It is less pricey in comparison.
Learn where Gator FX3 falls short. Click for details.
For side by side comparison of their specs, I assembled a table.
| Specification | BAKFlip F1 | Gator FX3 |
|---|---|---|
| Latching | Slam Latch with pull cord to unlock | Slam latches with pull cord to unlock |
| Panel Core | Aluminum Extruded Polystyrene Foam | Aluminum High Density Foam |
| Frame Material | Aluminum | Aluminum |
| Panel Exterior | Fibreglass Reinforced Polymer | Fibreglass Reinforced Polymer |
| Seal Material | EPDM Rubber | EPDM Seals |
| Coating | Scratch and UV Resistant | Scratch and UV Resistant |
| Installation | Clamp-On (no drill) | No-Drill Clamp-On |
| Weight Capacity | Up to 400 lbs (evenly distributed) | Up to 300 lbs (Evenly Distributed) |
| Cover Weight | 70 pounds (standard size) | 65 lbs Approx. |
| Bed Access | Full bed access | Full Bed Access |
| Tailgate Seal | Dual Action Tailgate Seal | Comes on top of the tailgate |
| Warranty | 5 years | 2 Years |
| Price Range | $1,049 – $1,299 | $1,049 to $1,089 |
Composition Comparison
BAKFlip F1 stands out with its heavy-duty triple folding design. The core of its panels is made from aluminum.
On the outside, these panels are wrapped in fiberglass-reinforced polymer (FRP). This material is known for being light weight and resistant to dents and scratches.
The frame is aluminum, which is a smart choice because it resists rust and corrosion.
The panels and frame are coated, giving them a sleek, finished look and added protection against the elements.
The latching system is pretty straightforward, but it’s also secure. You’ve got latches under the cover that hook into the bed rails.
However, keep in mind that while these latches are reliable, they might require occasional adjustments to ensure a snug fit.
Side Note: If you’re new to tonneau covers, be sure to check out my detailed article on “Things To Know Before Buying A Tonneau Cover” here https://toptonneaureview.com/tonneau-cover-buying-guide/
Now, switching focus towards Gator FX3. Its core material is also aluminum substrate, which is like the backbone of the cover, providing strength and durability.
The exterior of the panels is fiberglass. It is tough against routine wear and tear but, F1 isn’t completely impervious to dents.
The frame of the FX3 is also aluminum, maintaining that balance between strength and weight. The entire cover, including the frame, has a powder-coated finish.
This coating not only enhances its appearance but also offers extra protection against corrosion and scratches.
Furthermore, aluminum jaw grip clamps are provided to hold the cover in place.
For water resistance the cover comes with EPDM seals. However the tailgate area is not completely sealed and come some water gets into the truckbed in heavy rain.
Both covers provide full bed access with the help of prop rods.
To summarize, both BAKFlip F1 and Gator FX3 feature a durable aluminum base and a robust FRP top layer. They provide full bed access, are lightweight, and are designed for ease of use.
Ease of Use
Both covers offer excellent durability and ease of use. Both have a fold-up design for full bed access and easy maintenance.
Furthermore both F1 and F3 feature a user-friendly latch system and a low-profile design for improved aerodynamics.
An aerodynamically designed cover that sits flush with your truck bed reduces wind drag. This not only gives your truck a sleek look but also contributes to fuel efficiency.
Tonneau covers can influence your fuel efficiency for better or worse. Find out more https://toptonneaureview.com/do-tonneau-covers-improve-gas-mileage/
FX3, being slightly lighter than F1, offers greater fuel efficiency. However, the slightly heavier F1 may produce less noise, although the difference in is minimal.
Their durable construction requires straightforward maintenance, typically just a wash with water and mild soap.
However, it’s worth noting that the Gator FX3 may occasionally require hardware upgrades such as seals or hinges. BAKFlip F1 has an edge with better-quality hinges and seals.
In terms of security, both covers generally feature locking mechanisms integrated with the tailgate for easy securing.
Both covers feature a similar installation process and require the same amount of time to install. For a step by step installation guide, click here.
BAKFlip F1 offers superior water resistance with better seals and hinges, while Gator FX3 benefits from its lightweight design. Both require minimal maintenance.
Weather Performance
BAKFlip F1 is known for its premium EPDM weather seals and rounded-style hinges that ensure a snug fit, significantly reducing the chances of water and debris infiltration.
Its water drainage system effectively directs water away through drainage tubes, offering a high degree of water resistance.
Both covers have FRP top layer that guards against dents, scratches, and UV rays, ensuring the color stays vibrant and the surface remains unharmed.
Frames of both covers benefit from a powdered black finish, acting as a robust barrier against corrosion.
Regular inspection of the seals is crucial, step to prevent moisture from sneaking into my truck bed, especially before setting out on trips in rainy conditions.
Replacing any damaged seals under warranty is important to prevent moisture from entering your truck bed.
In terms of handling extreme weather, both covers are designed to withstand snow, hail, and rain. They are engineered to handle a significant amount of weight, making them reliable even under heavy snow accumulation.
Their performance in cold weather and snowy areas is reliable, maintaining a barrier against dust and snow intrusion.
Both offer good amount of protection, ensuring that your cargo stays secure, dry, and unaffected by the elements.
Both BAKFlip F1 and Gator FX3 exhibit comparable resilience in various weather conditions, offering robust protection with advanced sealing, water drainage, and durable materials. However, the F1 slightly edges out in water resistance.
Security
BAKFlip F1 is known for its robust construction, utilizing sturdy materials resistant to penetration from common tools used by thieves.
Its security is primarily accessed from the inside, requiring the tailgate to be opened and a cord to be pulled, which adds an extra layer of safety.
On the other hand, the Gator FX3 tonneau cover also provides substantial protection. It features a “slam latch” system that allows for a tighter closure and comes with individual locks for enhanced security.
The optional security package takes it a step further with a reinforced aluminum sub-frame and high-grade panels, making it tougher against attempted thefts.
Additionally, when paired with a locking tailgate, it significantly increases the overall security of your truck bed.
Both BAKFlip F1 Gator FX3 serve as strong deterrents against theft by keeping your cargo out of sight and adding physical barriers.
However, it’s always wise to exercise caution and not leave valuables unattended, as no system can guarantee total security.
Cost Comparison
When comparing the BAKFlip F1 and Gator FX3 tonneau covers, both are similarly priced with the F1 ranging from $1,049 to $1,299 and the FX3 from $1,049 to $1,089.
Despite their identical designs and materials, the F1 offers superior water resistance, making it a preferable choice for those in wetter climates.
Furthermore, the F1’s 5-year warranty has surpassed the FX3’s 2-year warranty.
While the initial costs are comparable, especially at the lower end, the F1’s higher price point may be justified for those valuing long-term protection and a more extended warranty.
In contrast, the FX3 represents a more budget-friendly option without the enhanced features of the F1.
In long term BAKFlip F1 is better choice as it comes with longer warranty.
Wrap Up
In conclusion, both tonneau covers offer robust protection and practicality, but with distinct advantages.
Design-and-usage-wise, both are similar, but the F1 is slightly better at resisting water and comes with a longer warranty.
BAKFlip F1 excels with superior water resistance, enhanced durability, and a longer warranty, catering to those seeking longevity and top-tier protection.
Conversely, the Gator FX3 offers a lighter, more user-friendly experience at a more accessible price point, though with some compromises in seal quality and water resistance.
